sskj/BENCHMARK_WORKFLOW.md

# Benchmark Workflow & Directory Conventions

## Directory Layout

```
/data/user1/yy/
├── platforms/                  # chip/accelerator platform configs
│   ├── kunlun_p800.env
│   ├── nvidia_h200.env
│   └── patches/kunlun_p800/    # runtime patches required by some images
├── scripts/                    # shared benchmark/orchestrator/utility scripts
│   ├── common/                 # reusable components (lib.sh, platform.sh, ...)
│   ├── analysis/               # cross-experiment comparison tools
│   ├── benchmark_dspark_0707/  # legacy DSpark benchmark suite
│   └── ...
├── experiments/                # experiment-centric directories (preferred)
│   └── dsv4_p800_sglang/
│       ├── README.md
│       ├── config.env          # experiment-level configuration
│       ├── start_server.sh
│       ├── run_bench.sh
│       ├── parse_results.py
│       └── results/
│           └── 20260708-XXXXXX/
│               ├── report.md
│               ├── results.json
│               └── logs/
├── bench_results/              # legacy benchmark outputs (read-only history)
│   ├── dspark_grid_20260707-132641/
│   └── ...
├── logs/                       # server logs (stdout/stderr from start scripts)
├── datasets/                   # benchmark datasets
└── envs/                       # Python virtual environments
```

## Rules

1. **Experiments are the primary organization unit.**
   - Each experiment lives under `experiments/<experiment_name>/` and contains its scripts, configuration, and results.
   - Shared orchestration code lives in `scripts/common/`; do not copy server start / health check logic into every experiment.
   - Legacy experiments may remain under `scripts/<group>/` with outputs in `bench_results/`, but new work should use `experiments/`.

2. **Benchmark outputs live with their experiment.**
   - For `experiments/<name>/`, results go in `experiments/<name>/results/<RUN_ID>/`.
   - Each run directory must contain `report.md` (human-readable) and `results.json` (structured data).
   - Raw outputs go in `raw_outputs/`; logs go in `logs/`.
   - Legacy `bench_results/<experiment>_<timestamp>/` directories remain valid for archived runs.

3. **Each `bench_results/<run>/` directory must contain two final artifacts.**
   - A Markdown report for human reading (e.g. `report.md`, `comparison_report.md`).
   - A JSON file with the complete structured result data for programmatic analysis (e.g. `results.json`).
   - The directory may also contain a `README.md` documenting provenance if the report alone does not cover it.

4. **Final JSON must contain raw/structured data, not just summary numbers.**
   - Metadata: experiment name, timestamp, model, backend/inference engine, hardware/accelerator, script path, environment/commit info.
   - Record the **chip/accelerator** (e.g. `NVIDIA H200`, `Kunlun XPU`) and the **inference engine** (e.g. `vllm-dspark`, `sglang`, `vllm-xpu`) explicitly. Do not infer them from directory names.
   - Per-scenario/per-configuration results: all request latencies, TTFT, TPOT, ITL, token counts, throughput, accept length, success/failure counts.
   - Include P50 / P90 / P95 / P99 percentiles where applicable.
   - Keep the schema stable so downstream Python scripts can parse all experiments uniformly.
   - See [Final JSON Schema](#final-json-schema) below for the recommended structure.

5. **Scripts should default `RESULT_ROOT` to the experiment's results directory.**
   - For `experiments/<name>/run_bench.sh`, default to `experiments/<name>/results/${RUN_ID}/`.
   - For legacy scripts, default to `bench_results/<experiment>_${RUN_ID}/`.
   - Allow override via `RESULT_ROOT` env var.
   - Use `RUN_ID=$(date '+%Y%m%d-%H%M%S')` unless specified.

6. **Server start scripts write to `logs/`.**
   - `logs/<service>_<timestamp>.log`
   - Keep server logs separate from benchmark result logs.

7. **Scripts and outputs must record chip/accelerator and inference engine.**
   - Every benchmark script should capture or accept the platform and engine it is running on (e.g. via environment variables `CHIP`, `ACCELERATOR`, `ENGINE`, `BACKEND`, or auto-detection).
   - Final reports and JSON outputs must include both the accelerator/chip family and the inference engine/backend used for the run.
   - Do not rely on the experiment name alone to identify the platform or engine.

8. **Use platform configuration files for chip-specific constants.**
   - Put per-platform settings in `platforms/<chip>.env` (e.g. `platforms/kunlun_p800.env`, `platforms/nvidia_h200.env`).
   - Scripts load the platform file via `scripts/common/platform.sh`; the active platform is selected by the `PLATFORM` env var or auto-detected.
   - Keep experiment scripts free of hardcoded device IDs, image names, or model root paths.

## Naming Conventions

### Experiment result directories

For experiment-centric layout:

```
experiments/<experiment>/results/<YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS>/
```

Examples:

- `experiments/dsv4_p800_sglang/results/20260708-120000/`
- `experiments/dspark_grid/results/20260707-132641/`

The `results.json` metadata already records `chip`/`accelerator` and `engine`, so the directory path does not need to encode them. If a single experiment must distinguish across platforms in its directory tree, use:

```
experiments/<experiment>/results/<chip>_<engine>_<YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS>/
```

### Legacy result directories

```
bench_results/<experiment>_<YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS>/
```

Examples:

- `bench_results/dspark_grid_20260707-132641/`
- `bench_results/dsv4_backend_comparison_20260707/`

### Raw output files

Include the accelerator and inference engine in raw output filenames so files from different platforms cannot overwrite each other.

For detailed per-request JSONL outputs:

```
{chip}_{engine}_{MMDD}_{concurrency}_{input_len}_{output_len}.jsonl
```

For summary JSON outputs from `sglang.bench_serving --output-file`:

```
{chip}_{engine}_{scenario}_{params}.json
```

### Logs

```
logs/<service>_YYYYMMDD_HHMMSS.log
logs/<experiment>_orchestrator_YYYYMMDD_HHMMSS.log
```

## Final JSON Schema

The JSON file inside each `bench_results/<run>/` directory should follow a stable schema so that downstream Python scripts can load every experiment the same way. The file is usually named `results.json`.

### Required top-level fields

```json
{
  "metadata": {
    "experiment": "dspark_grid",
    "run_id": "20260707-132641",
    "timestamp": "2026-07-07T13:26:41+08:00",
    "model": "/data/models/DeepSeek-V4-Flash-DSpark",
    "backend": "vllm-dspark",
    "engine": "vllm-dspark",
    "hardware": "8x NVIDIA H200 143GB",
    "accelerator": "NVIDIA H200",
    "chip": "NVIDIA H200",
    "script": "scripts/benchmark_dspark_0707/run_dspark_benchmark_grid.sh",
    "env": "/data/user1/yy/envs/vllm-dspark",
    "git_commit": "optional git sha",
    "description": "optional free-text note"
  },
  "config": {
    "tp": 8,
    "kv_cache_dtype": "fp8",
    "spec_method": "dspark",
    "spec_tokens": 5,
    "block_size": 256,
    "max_num_seqs": 256,
    "extra_args": "--no-disable-hybrid-kv-cache-manager"
  },
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "name": "chat_short",
      "concurrency": 64,
      "input_len": 1000,
      "output_len": 256,
      "duration_s": 21.27,
      "success": 512,
      "failed": 0,
      "request_throughput": 24.07,
      "input_token_throughput": 6391.14,
      "output_token_throughput": 3189.39,
      "total_token_throughput": 9580.52,
      "accept_length": 3.2,
      "latencies": {
        "e2e_ms": { "mean": 2547.81, "p50": 2400.0, "p90": 4800.0, "p95": 5606.07, "p99": 6543.97 },
        "ttft_ms": { "mean": 268.68, "p50": 240.0, "p90": 480.0, "p95": 543.21, "p99": 588.63 },
        "tpot_ms": { "mean": 18.24, "p50": 16.0, "p90": 28.0, "p95": 30.39, "p99": 39.57 },
        "itl_ms": { "mean": 70.29, "p50": 60.0, "p90": 110.0, "p95": 130.0, "p99": 160.0 }
      },
      "raw_requests": [
        {
          "request_id": "uuid-or-index",
          "input_tokens": 1000,
          "output_tokens": 256,
          "e2e_ms": 2500.0,
          "ttft_ms": 260.0,
          "tpot_ms": 18.0,
          "itl_ms": 70.0,
          "accept_length": 3.0,
          "success": true
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}
```

### Notes

- `raw_requests` is optional but recommended when the JSON size is manageable. If a single run produces millions of requests, store per-request data as `raw_outputs/*.jsonl` and keep only aggregated percentiles in `results.json`.
- Always include **P50 / P90 / P95 / P99** for TTFT, TPOT, E2E, and ITL. P95 is the primary SLO metric.
- Keep field names snake_case and consistent across experiments.
- Record hardware and engine information explicitly:
  - `accelerator` / `chip`: the accelerator family, e.g. `NVIDIA H200`, `Kunlun XPU`, `AMD MI300X`.
  - `engine` / `backend`: the inference engine or serving backend, e.g. `vllm-dspark`, `sglang`, `vllm-xpu`.
  - `hardware`: a human-readable full hardware description, e.g. `8x NVIDIA H200 143GB`, `8x Kunlun XPU R480`.
  - Keep at least one of `accelerator` or `chip`, and at least one of `engine` or `backend`, populated in every run.
- If a metric is not applicable (e.g. `accept_length` for non-speculative decoding), set it to `null` rather than omitting the key.

## Quick Start

### Run P800 SGLang benchmark (Kunlun P800, Docker)

```bash
bash experiments/dsv4_p800_sglang/run_bench.sh
```

### Run H200 DSpark benchmark (NVIDIA H200, native venv)

```bash
bash experiments/dsv4_h200_dspark/run_bench.sh
```

### Run legacy DSpark grid benchmark

```bash
bash scripts/benchmark_dspark_0707/run_dspark_benchmark_grid.sh
```

### Run DSpark spec-tokens comparison

```bash
bash scripts/benchmark_dspark_0707/run_dspark_st_comparison.sh
```

### Parse results

```bash
# Experiment-centric layout
python3 experiments/dsv4_p800_sglang/parse_results.py \
  experiments/dsv4_p800_sglang/results/<run_id>

# Legacy layout
/data/user1/yy/envs/sglang/bin/python scripts/benchmark_dspark_0707/parse_results.py \
  /data/user1/yy/bench_results/dspark_grid_<run_id>
```

### Cross-experiment comparison

```bash
python3 scripts/analysis/compare_experiments.py
```

## Adding a New Platform or Experiment

### 1. Add or update a platform config

Create `platforms/<chip>.env` with identity and platform-wide paths:

```bash
CHIP="my_chip"
ACCELERATOR="My Accelerator"
HARDWARE="8x My Accelerator"
ENGINE="vllm-myengine"
DEFAULT_PORT="30000"
MODEL_ROOT="/data/models"
```

For Docker-based platforms, also set `DOCKER_IMAGE`, `CONTAINER_NAME`,
`CONTAINER_PYTHON`, and `PATCH_ROOT` (see `platforms/kunlun_p800.env`).
For host-native platforms, set the relevant venv paths (see
`platforms/nvidia_h200.env`).

### 2. Create an experiment directory

```
experiments/<name>/
├── README.md          # Purpose and usage
├── config.env         # Model, port, scenarios, engine overrides
├── start_server.sh    # (optional) platform-specific server launch
├── run_bench.sh       # Orchestrator
└── parse_results.py   # Convert raw outputs to results.json + report.md
```

At minimum, `run_bench.sh` should:

1. Source `scripts/common/lib.sh` and `scripts/common/platform.sh`.
2. Read `config.env`.
3. Create `experiments/<name>/results/<RUN_ID>/`.
4. Call `write_metadata_json` to create `results.json`.
5. Run the benchmark scenarios.
6. Call `parse_results.py` to generate `report.md`.

### 3. Reuse shared helpers

- `scripts/common/lib.sh`: logging, health checks, metadata JSON.
- `scripts/common/platform.sh`: platform auto-detection and env loading.
- `scripts/common/server_docker.sh`: Docker-based server lifecycle.
- `scripts/common/bench_client_docker.sh`: run `sglang.bench_serving` inside a container.

Native (non-Docker) platforms can delegate to existing start scripts or add
new shared helpers under `scripts/common/`.

### 4. Example experiments

- Docker / XPU: `experiments/dsv4_p800_sglang/`
- Native / H200: `experiments/dsv4_h200_dspark/`

See `docs/H200_QUICKSTART.md` for a concrete H200 porting walkthrough.

## Checklist Before Committing / Archiving

- [ ] No `.jsonl`, `.json`, `.log`, or `.md` files left in the project root.
- [ ] For `experiments/<name>/`, outputs live in `experiments/<name>/results/<timestamp>/`.
- [ ] For legacy runs, outputs live in `bench_results/<experiment>_<timestamp>/`.
- [ ] `<run>/report.md` (or equivalent human-readable `.md`) exists.
- [ ] `<run>/results.json` exists and follows the [Final JSON Schema](#final-json-schema).
- [ ] `<run>/results.json` metadata records the `chip`/`accelerator` and `engine`/`backend` used.
- [ ] Raw output filenames include the chip/accelerator and engine when cross-platform runs may collide.
- [ ] `<run>/README.md` exists and documents provenance (or the report itself covers provenance).
- [ ] Scripts either live under `experiments/<name>/` or in `scripts/` (or `scripts/<group>/`).
- [ ] Script path references updated after moving.